Roped into a trip to a table-tennis tournament in rural Michigan, my husband and I found ourselves pulling up to a middle-budget motel that promised relentless air-conditioning during a weekend of 100-degree weather. Our motel was on the same stretch as a small Baptist church, an adult boutique that claimed to have revitalized the lives of many couples, a big-box grocery store where the greeter said “God Bless You,” and several fast-food joints. As we were checking into the motel, an Indian teenager dressed in a T-shirt and basketball shorts emerged from a doorway connected to the reception area and hopped into a car parked in the lot. I figured him for a high schooler working a summer job. But during our three-day stay, it became clear that he lived in the motel. On occasion, I would see him carrying plastic bags loaded with vegetables from the nearby Bombay Grocers, or in the lobby watching a music video on his laptop. The older Indian woman working the front desk caught me staring at him, and the next time I walked by he was still watching music videos but now had his headphones on.
Sociologist Pawan Dhingra was not looking to write a book about Indian motel owners when he met some in Alabama. Yet he found himself drawn to what he described as the “exciting and multifaceted dynamic” of their lives as they attempted to create a space for their families and to build a community for themselves. In Life Behind the Lobby: Indian American Motel Owners and the American Dream, he invites us to consider the two contrasting narratives that frame the lives of these motel owners and their families. The first narrative is one of astonishing success. Indian Americans nationally own roughly 60 percent of what he calls budget-oriented motels and more than half of franchise motels built in recent years. A few months ago, Buffalo News marveled that, while Indian Americans only make up only 0.3 percent of the Niagara County population, they own nearly all of the budget motels near the Falls. Manjit Saran, who was the first Indian to own motels on the popular tourist strip, said, “It’s not Niagara Falls Boulevard anymore. You can call it Indian Boulevard.”
In fact, Saran’s last name makes him a minority in the Indian American motel circuit. Almost three-quarters of Indian American motel owners have the same last name: Patel. In a 1999 New York Times article catchily titled “A Patel Motel Cartel?” an interviewee passed on the family joke when he said, “In some American small towns they think ‘Patel’ is an Indian word for motel.” While the Patels are not all related to each other, they do either come directly from Gujarat or by way of East Africa or the United Kingdom. This is apparently because the first Indian motel owner in the United States was a Gujerati. Kanjibhai Desai purchased a residential hotel called the Goldfield in San Francisco in the 1940s; his hotel drew other Gujeratis who were working as laborers and needed a place to stay. Once there, these laborers gained insight into the advantages of the hospitality business. The self-employment that the motel industry offered was very attractive to these and other newly-immigrated Gujeratis who spoke little English and were contending with discriminatory labor practices
The stunning success of these motel owners has not gone unnoticed by American politicians. Dhingra opens his book noting the numerous political bigwigs such as Al Gore, Bill Clinton, Bob Dole and Newt Gingrich who have spoken at conventions made up nearly entirely of Indian American motel owners:
Indian American motel owners appear as the American dream incarnate -- self-employed, self-sufficient, boot-strapping immigrants who have become successful without government intervention. Regardless of the political ideology, these keynote speakers invoke the ‘model minority’ stereotype to describe Indian American motel-owners, praising them as a group that has overcome obstacles on the road to greater achievement and implying that racial or cultural inequality is no longer an issue.
In our telephone conversation, Dhingra spoke compellingly of the American dream as an important through-line in his book. “The American dream was relevant from the beginning but it’s more complicated than a thumbs up or thumbs down. I didn’t want to tell a simple narrative. I wanted to bring together contrasting narratives.” Thus, even as we are wowed by the dramatic rise of Indian motel ownership, which Dhingra meticulously chronicles for us, he juxtaposes that narrative against the day-to-day realities of this industry. One of Dhingra’s informants recalls a phone call he received from the franchise corporation regarding a pre-existing highway billboard for a motel he had just purchased. The representative asked him if he realized that the billboard had an American flag on it. She then awkwardly proceeded to intimate that he was not really American, whatever his passport may say.
The use of the American flag to undermine Indian-owned motels is by no means a recent innovation. In a collection of essays about the Great Plains in the 1980s, Jim Hoy and Tom Isern wrote of coming across numerous “Asian Indians” running motels in Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas, and seeing American flags pop up in front of competing motels to signal white ownership. One sign in Oklahoma read “Okie Owned.”
While many owners felt that they had seen a decrease in racist encounters with customers, they could still recall a few. There were the customers who left upon discovering that the motel was Indian-owned. The more subtle ones would drive through the parking lot cautiously while trying to ascertain the ethnicity of the owners before driving off. An independent motel owner in Toledo said, “When you treat [non-Indians] good, they so, oh, you are good. When you tell them you cannot do this, then they tell you, you are a foreigner.” Dhingra notes that it’s very likely that the motel owners underestimated the number of times their non-Indian workers may have ameliorated the anxieties of customers without informing the owners themselves. One white desk clerk told Dhingra that it was not unusual to be asked if the owners were “Arabs or Iraqis.”
Dhingra charts the myriad ways in which Indian motel owners may imbue the lobby with an aura of acceptability. This includes hiring white women as desk clerks, assigning one’s children to help with chores in the motel but keeping them out of sight in key areas such as the lobby, and ensuring that guests cannot smell any Indian food being cooked in the family’s quarters. This last strategy was particularly important to a number of Dhingra’s informants, some going so far as to install an exhaust system to dispel the aroma of the food. Dhingra even recalls an Ohio-based motelier who placed the well-known Christian plaque of praying hands above the front desk despite being a practicing Hindu.
These motel owners and their families offer striking glimpses of what one might imagine as an isolating landscape in which to live. Talking about the dearth of dining options for a vegetarian in Lima, OH, one motelier said, “I go to Taco Bell and get things with beans. Burger King has a veggie patty.” There’s something interesting going on when Burger King becomes a Hindu’s source for vegetarian food. Simultaneously, it’s clear that they do attempt to form some sort of community where possible, whether it is through regular volleyball games among male owners or going to a Hindu temple in the nearest city.
Dhingra’s book is unique in that while he obtains his data from motel owners in a variety of American states, Ohio forms the backbone of this work. “The Midwest has a key role in the American consciousness. It’s known as the heartland and the heartland invites images of a nostalgic past, whiteness (tempered by blackness),” he said. In his book, Dhingra elaborates: “Ohio and other Midwestern sites (with the exception of Chicago) have been overlooked not only in discussions of Indian Americans and Asian Americans but also in discussions of immigration as a whole.”
When I asked Dhingra to recall a particularly memorable individual or family, he was momentarily stumped. Then, he began telling me about the female motel-owner in Wisconsin who said that she felt sorry for women who had to work outside their home since she could both live and work in her motel. Next, he told me about the motel owner who saw himself as “a miniature Donald Trump,” and looked back derisively on his time as an engineer trapped in the layers of corporate hierarchy. It became clear to me that had he not had a flight to catch that afternoon, Dhingra might have told me about every single person who had invited him into the intimate spaces of their lives -- behind the lobby, and into the community well beyond.
* * *
Dashini Jeyathurai is a doctoral candidate in the joint PhD program in English and Women’s Studies at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. She blogs for the South Asian American Digital Archive and has an article forthcoming in The Journal of Commonwealth Literature.
You've just read a post from Across the Desk: a collaboration of Asian American journalists and scholars. See here for more in the series. Scholars and journalists interested in contributing, please email the series editor at erin[at]hyphenmagazine[dot]com.
The previous issue of Hyphen is available in its entirety for your perusing pleasure. Almost as good as having it right in your hands!