The Asian Gals on America's Next Top Model

September 20, 2006

The last time there was a South Asian woman (actually, the only other time) was Julie from season 2. She got axed after only two weeks on the show because she admitted she was more interested in starting a garment company than being a model. Doh.

Let’s hope that Anchal has got her act more together than Gina from last season. Seriously, anyone would be better than Gina, who was so clueless and confused. First she says, she’s proud to be Asian and wants to represent since there aren't many Asian models. Then in the same interview, she says she doesn’t date Asian men. What’s up with that? Even Tyra Banks called her on the contradiction. In a later episode, during a mock press conference, Janice Dickinson asks her how being Asian affects her desire to be a model. Gina meekly answers that she doesn’t know. When pressed, she says she’s having an identity crisis. Sigh. Why do you have to have your identity crisis on national TV?

Sadly, Gina (who is Korean) seemed to fulfill the stereotype of the model minority: didn’t stick up for herself, let others bully her, quietly and passively did what she was told in hopes that she would be recognized and achieve her dream.

Here’s a clip of the disaster that is Gina:

Of all the Asian Americans on ANTM, I kind of miss April, who is half Japanese, from Season 2.

top model april.jpg

She seemed strong and confident. I was rooting for her to win. I found it interesting that on the one hand, judges would tell her to embrace her Asian heritage more. But then they would stereotype her too, saying she didn’t show enough emotion and was like a workaholic robot in pursuit of technical perfection.

Here’s an interview with April.

So, here's the essay question for today: Reality TV, good or not for minority representation?

Contributor: 

Melissa Hung

Founding Editor

Melissa Hung is the founding editor of Hyphen. She was the editor in chief for the magazine's first five years and went on to serve in many other leadership roles on the staff and board for more than a decade. She is a writer and freelance journalist. Her essays and reported stories have appeared in NPR, Vogue, Pacific Standard, Longreads, and Catapult, among others. She grew up in Texas, the eldest child of immigrants. Find her on Twitter and Instagram.

Comments

Comments

sorry, I meant ANTM :)
Everyone wants to be an American. For the most part, it does not matter where you come from, people will see you as an Asian (Alien) first and always question your so called Americaness. Thats if you are not White, or Black. Anchal is dark and beautiful, which appears to be a problem with a few selective bloggers that believes the Euroasian or European look is the standard of beauty for all models emulate. Anchal can be my model anytime
well first there should not be any asians.... why? because the USA has so few of them. if the populations is 3% asian that means every 6 shows they should have one. that is 100% right and fair. second is asian are not tall enough to be high fashion models, are other races. its not about diversity its about choosing the right person for the job. no bending the rules to make asians feel good. models are tall as it should be. they look the best in clothes. its not about making other races feel special if they are not special. grow up and stop focusing on your race, your all racist who do that. keep the bloodlines pure and stick to you own kind. diversity is bad for everyone.
well first there should not be any asians.... why? because the USA has so few of them. if the populations is 3% asian that means every 6 shows they should have one. that is 100% right and fair. second is asian are not tall enough to be high fashion models, are other races. its not about diversity its about choosing the right person for the job. no bending the rules to make asians feel good. models are tall as it should be. they look the best in clothes. its not about making other races feel special if they are not special. grow up and stop focusing on your race, your all racist who do that. keep the bloodlines pure and stick to you own kind. diversity is bad for everyone.
AND YES THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS ARE WHITES..... AND HAVE BEEN FOR 100S OF YEAR. THE RECENT EMIGRANTS TO THE USA, IE ASIANS ARE REPRESENTORY OF THE FIRST AMERICANS NOR THE CURRENT AMERICA. GET OVER AND STOP YOUR RACISM AGAINST WHITES. YOU FREAKS ARE ALL FOCUSED ON RACE ALL THE TIME, YOU WEAR IT LIKE A BADGE OF HONOR AND UNFOUNDE PRIDE IN IT. IF ANYONE SHOULD BE BRAGGING AND PRIDEFUL IT SHOULD BE THE WHITE, THEY INVENTED EVERYTHING. FUNNY YOU NEVER SEE WHITES PRIDEFUL ABOUT THIER RACE OR SITES DEVOTED TO THIER HERITAGE.... IF THEY DID YOU FREAKS WOULD PUT THE RACIST LABEL ON THEM. YOU PEOPLE ARE THE TRUE RACIST. YOUR SO AFRAID YOU WILL NOT BE GOOD ENOUGH OR CONSIDERED ENOUGH YOU NEED TO GO BACK TO YOUR HOMELAND AND QUIT TRYING TO MAKE WHITE AMERICA BOW TO YOU. GO BACK TO ASIAN TOWN IF WHAT TO FIT IN AND EVERYTHING ABOUT YOUR CULTURE. YOUR COMPLETELY WRONG AND SELFISH. ITS A GOOD THING WONDERFUL GOOD AMERICANS DONT COMPLAIN AND DO WHAT DO, YOU WOULD OF BEEN DEPORT BY NOW.
Should we say gina is the stereotypical asian girl that dates *only* white men?
Should we say gina is the stereotypical asian girl that dates *only* white men?
Im indian,and i personally think dear anchal, aint that gorgeous.70% of the worlds indian girls look better than her.tyra is nuts saying shes got scary beauty.
I would just like to say I recently tried out for antm cycle ten in indianapolis and I did not see really any asian girls, just mainly african amrerican, white, and maybe two hispanic/latin american girls. It was strange to tell some of these girls i was asian when in fact they thought i was hispanic or brazilian even. I just think asian girls need to become more of a fashion icon in the modeling industry...I mean we have tyra, giselle, twiggy...what asian girl will be next?
Anchal would probably last longer. She can at least pass for an African American!
I find q April was the best when empese to see America `s nex top model supported keity because I gave as a penalty: (after he left empese April to support and when support was amercedesUnfortunately for my gain joanna: (but it is equally well toBye soy chili =)
Anchal has the best chance of an Asian girl winning ANTM since April.Everyone keeps saying how stunning she is. And that body is OFF THE HOOK.Sorry, I'm a guy.And just as important, she takes no crap from anyone (unlike Gina).I like the way she was the only one with the balls enough to confront Monique... who was hogging the telephone.

Pages