« Hyphen Family Issue Publishing Soon |
Main
| R.I.P. Al Robles »
It's May, peoples! It's Asian and Pacific Islander Heritage Month! This year is also the 20th Anniversary of the publication of Amy Tan's classic Asian American immigrant novel, The Joy Luck Club.
We have a love/hate relationship with that book. Love because it was our first foray into the mainstream of American fiction, a moment of broad self-acknowledgment many Asian Americans remember with fondness. Hate for many reasons: because it focused on women to the detriment of men (for a perspective, see Alvin's comments here); because it proposed an immigrant arc similar to that of Europeans, glossing over the continuing issues Asian immigrants have in this country; because it was so successful it coerced a generation of Asian American novelists to Joy Luck their way into a writing career.
So, to express our ambivalent Happy Birthday, here's a bouquet of tiny immigration tales. These are 300-word, true stories, from real Asian Americans, that complicate and argue with the story The Joy Luck Club tells. The complete awesomeness, vitality, and real diversity of these stories is exactly what my problem with the Joy Lucking of Asian American writing is about. We always knew these stories were out there; I just didn't know we could get so many great ones in such a short time.
(My only caveat is that we didn't get enough stories from men. Imagine how much broader the range would be if we had! Maybe next year ...)
Enjoy(luck)!
May 1, 2009
The Joy Luck Hub Blog Carnival: Asian American Immigrant Stories!
It's May, peoples! It's Asian and Pacific Islander Heritage Month! This year is also the 20th Anniversary of the publication of Amy Tan's classic Asian American immigrant novel, The Joy Luck Club.
We have a love/hate relationship with that book. Love because it was our first foray into the mainstream of American fiction, a moment of broad self-acknowledgment many Asian Americans remember with fondness. Hate for many reasons: because it focused on women to the detriment of men (for a perspective, see Alvin's comments here); because it proposed an immigrant arc similar to that of Europeans, glossing over the continuing issues Asian immigrants have in this country; because it was so successful it coerced a generation of Asian American novelists to Joy Luck their way into a writing career.
So, to express our ambivalent Happy Birthday, here's a bouquet of tiny immigration tales. These are 300-word, true stories, from real Asian Americans, that complicate and argue with the story The Joy Luck Club tells. The complete awesomeness, vitality, and real diversity of these stories is exactly what my problem with the Joy Lucking of Asian American writing is about. We always knew these stories were out there; I just didn't know we could get so many great ones in such a short time.
(My only caveat is that we didn't get enough stories from men. Imagine how much broader the range would be if we had! Maybe next year ...)
Enjoy(luck)!
- Blogger atlasien turns the mixed-race story upside down a few times: Joy Luck Hub Submission
He used to sing me to sleep with "God save the queen, iza fascist regime," which he intoned in a bizarre but somewhat credible imitation of a cockney accent.
- Michelle Phan on discovering her immigrant story for school: Grandmother's Story
When I was in Jr. High, my social studies class was assigned a project, a family timeline. I thought it was going to be easy, just from Laos to America. But as I sat there pondering what events to include, I was stumped; I didn’t know how my family got to America.
- Artist Jennifer Wofford on the complicated lines of migration: we be joy luck clubbin'
My mom, tito and tita spent their preteen and teen years on Guam, attending a tiny missionary school there. It’s a little unclear financially how, but somehow Lolo sent all 3 kids off to college in the U.S. My mom and aunt were probably the only 2 Filipinas/Asians in Walla Walla, Washington in the late 50’s: they quickly bonded with 2 Japanese-American sisters there as well.
- ennie18 on a sibling's romance: Brother's Story
My brother and his fiancé met in middle school and dated in high school. After high school, they even went to college together. While talking about their refugee camp experience, they found out they were in the same refugee camp once.
- Blogger Ernie of little. yellow. different. blog on seeing the movie with his family: The Joy Luck Club
... sometimes I wonder if my parents were somehow fortold what would happen — that their daughter would succumb to mental illness and their son would become an overweight homosexual with a penchant for putting his private life to share with the Internet — if they would perservere and stay in the United States, or if they would turn around and go right back to where they came from.
- Hana of Hana Logic blog on her first American crush: Joy Luck Hub Submission: A tiny anecdote circa 1998
I have never been in a class with boys before, having been raised in a convent school in the Philippines since I was six. But there he was, already tall for his age with fair skin and blonde hair. The Hollywood ideal that I saw in American T.V. shows in Manila when I was allowed to watch.
- Jane Voodikon on the confusions of family storytelling: forty years
I vividly recall in my mother’s version of the story, she escaped to Hong Kong. The verb was always the key part. My father, in his secondhand version of the same story, said that she smuggled out to Hong Kong, on the bottom of a boat. I thought she got to the U.S. by plane. My sister, then an attorney fresh out of law school, in her write-up of the account said she sailed.
- Kimberley of A Companion Piece blog on how alternative families are nothing new: queer luck club
My great-uncle was not a blood relative. His sister and my great-aunt were life partners, in love with one another since their teens. My great-aunt married her lover’s brother, who was then in the U.S. The two women joined my great-uncle in Stockton, and the three were a family for more than half a century.
- Hyphen blogger Catherine Traywick in her Femmalia blog with more complicated back-and-forthing : My Mother's Migration Story
When I was born, my father decided that I should grow up in the Philippines where I would be safe from the evils of Western society, and so we moved back to Mom’s home town where she proudly paraded me as the only half-white baby around for miles and miles.
- Lilledeshan Bose on incremental migration: Joy Luck Clubish? An Immigrant Story
I made the decision to move to the United States in increments. At first I was going to stay a month, then three, then I found myself the lead singer of a rock n roll band and decided to stay. Now I’ve been in the country six years; the band doesn’t exist anymore but I’ve lived in five cities (in two states) since opting to stay in Orange County.
- Artist Johanna Poethig (in Jenifer Wofford's blog) on growing up an American Asian: Joy Luck Club: Johanna Poethig
My first profanity was “putang ina mo”. My best friend in 3rd grade got mad at me after she learned the Americans killed Aguinaldo. ... In 5th grade I finally got to be in a school performance. The Ifugao ceremony where we all moved together around a fire did not require pairing me off with a boy half my size.
- Mo on the details the grand immigrant story gets wrong: the joy luck hub (and this comment seems to have disappeared from the call for subs post. Dunno how that happened.)
My parents ran away from Cambodia not because they didn’t want to fight, but because my mom was pregnant with me (and pregnancy isn’t convenient during war.) ... When I was 12, I was called ‘chink’ for the first time. It bothered me more that someone had taught this other child a racial slur, than the fact that he was calling me a name. It didn’t occur to me that it should have felt odd for me to be desensitized to the word.
- Melinda of Women's Work blog on transracial adoption and immigration: One Foot In, One Foot Out (In Honor of the 20th Anniversary of The Joy Luck Club)
Still, I am an unlikely first-generation immigrant of sorts. I’m a Korean adoptee of unknown origins...found, fostered and foisted onto American soil, into the waiting arms of a caring, typically-Caucasian middle-class family. That makes me a product of a typically-Caucasian middle-class suburban upbringing, except – somehow – I don’t feel typical at all.
- Angela at mommybytes blog on grad school immigration: Asian American Immigration - My Parents' Story
They found advertisements in science journals for the University of North Dakota which offered full scholarships. They applied to the Chemistry department and were accepted, but had no money for air travel. Linda's father decided to give money to John for airfare in 1962. After a year, Linda was given the airfare to go. They often said that they picked North Dakota because they wanted to live someplace cold because Taiwan was so hot.
- kim of c'est la vie blog on loss of language: one lucky day
honestly, i didn’t consciously try to forget my first language. it just happened … through overcompensation, or something. over the years i’ve been trying to improve, but something else prevented me from succeeding: a lack of self-confidence. a fear of sounding stupid, making mistakes and consequently, a fool of myself. after overcoming so many barriers, i can’t believe this is the one i still can’t defeat.
- Bernie at Prouder Never Always blog on representing his entire race: Eye-closing Experience
Right there and then, upon my shoulders was placed the entire reputation of the Chinese people.
- And last (and very definitely least) my own entry on the tangled trajectories of the overseas Chinese: Traditional Immigrant Story
Great-great-grandfather went to San Francisco to pluck duck feathers and carve candles. Great-grandfather didn't join him in the States. Why? It's possible that, returning to Zhong Shan, Great-great blew all the money he had saved on gifts and banquets and couldn't afford to bring his only son over.
Posted by Claire at May 1, 2009 7:37 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.hyphenmagazine.com/cgi-bin/blog/mt-tb.cgi/1595






Thanks Claire for putting this together! I look forward to reading all the entries and put a link to this post as well.
yes, thank you! this is awesome!
In case anyone's hungry for more immigration stories, here's mine: http://nutellaicecream.wordpress.com/2009/05/01/capturing-a-bit-of-family-history/
I love those stories that were collected; it shows the breadth and diversity of immigrant experiences.
I still take issue with calling that garbage book a "classic", or even saying there's a "love/hate" relationship. I would say that it's mostly just hate. I don't feel comfortable celebrating any sort of "Happy Birthday" for that book.
Just because it achieved commercial success by pandering, doesn't mean we should celebrate or even recognize its publication date. I would rather it simply be ignored and forgotten.
I would also speculate that there were less AAM submissions because of JLC's anti-Asian-male nature. It's similar to why one would expect less letter to the editor submissions from women for a celebration anniversary of Maxim.
Okay Alvin, I think you said everything you needed to say in our previous exchange. Now I feel that you're just pushing your views on others.
At least a couple of people have stated in their stories or in comments that JLC meant a lot to them back when they first read it ... and still does mean something to them. You continuing to 'take issue with calling that garbage book a "classic", or even saying there's a "love/hate" relationship' sounds like you're invalidating other people's responses to the book (including my own.)
You've gotten a platform here to air your views, and, although I've disagreed with you, I think your views have been treated with respect. I'd ask you to treat other people's views the same way.
i have a couple more immigration stories to share if anyone is interested. one is from me and the other is from a friend. they're at:
californiaburrito.tumblr.com